STRUCTURING ON-THE-JOB
TRAINING
By
Sam
Boyer
The performance level attained by
new employees will rise through the use of effective training programs.
However, many times the new employees that are hired at the entry level or
just above are "given" to an existing employee to train without
regard to their ability to train. Furthermore exactly what tasks the new
employee is to be trained to perform is never clearly defined.
The only direction the trainer is
given is to "teach him to be a good Delivery Driver". This is
not enough. Having clearly defined training objectives, a structured
on-the-job training program, qualified trainers, and evaluation of the
results will provide your beer distributorship with improved performance
from new hires and existing employees. The new hires will have less
anxiety and are less likely to leave after a short employment period. The
structured training will give them the confidence they will need to
succeed in their new position. The new hires also benefit from structured
on-the-job training because they have an opportunity to learn a new skill
while earning an income and they have a chance to improve the quality of
their life.
From their success comes your
success as a beer distributor. Properly trained employees are the key to
high-quality customer service, improved sales and market share growth, and
profits. Investing in a structured on-the-job training program is an
essential element of distributorship success. This relatively low cost
approach to training new hires is gaining recognition for it flexibility
and effectiveness. It is also gaining respect among training
professionals. On-the-job training programs are no longer viewed as the
"black sheep" they once were.
SUPPORT THE PROGRAM
Owners and managers of
distributorships must take an active role in structured on-the-job
training programs if they are to be effective. You must support without
question the program, its objectives, the trainers, and provide corrective
feedback when results do not meet the objectives that were established.
Your involvement from the beginning is essential; provide input to the
objectives, help identify the positions to be included in the program,
select the trainers, and be an ongoing part of the evaluation process.
Making structured on-the-job training part of the culture on your
distributorship will allow it and training in general to become second
nature to your employees.
DETERMINE THE OBJECTIVES
What (by position) do you want
the structured on-the-job training program to achieve? Using the Delivery
Driver position as an example you can set objectives for rotation, vehicle
operating costs, overtime, damaged product, reduced turnover, etc. The
objectives that are set initially must be somewhat effort stretching but
attainable.
In an effort to get off to a
successful start you may want to limit the number of objectives to one or
two. The overall success of structured on-the-job training is tied to
setting objectives; if you do not set meaningful objectives you will never
know if the program is doing what it is intended to do.
IDENTIFY POSITIONS FOR OJT
Just about every position within
a beer distributorship can be included within a structured on-the-job
training program. However, in order to provide initial success you may
want to start with just one or two positions. Typically these positions
should be the entry level positions or one step above. These positions may
include Route Assistant, Line Cleaner, Warehouseman, Loader, Forklift
Operator, Delivery Driver, and even Driver Salesperson. Regardless of the
positions, select one and work to optimize the structured on-the-job
training program for it. After you are satisfied with the results select
another position and develop the training program for it. Continue
developing and testing on-the-job training modules for each position
within your organization until all are covered by the program.
WHAT ARE THE TRAINING NEEDS?
Determining the training needs is
simply finding the difference between the requirements of the position and
what skills the new employee already possesses. If your new employee was
hired to be a Delivery Driver one of the primary requirements will be his
ability to drive your delivery vehicles. If he has this skill
(demonstrated by a road test) and a valid CDL obviously you do not need to
spend training time in this area.
You will be able to move on to
package identification, morning check-out procedures, safety, lifting,
2-wheel operations, customer service, rotation, merchandising, hand-held
operations, and check-in procedures. These are the areas your newly hired
Delivery Driver will cover in the on-the-job training with your trainer(s).
The more structured the training the sooner the new Delivery Driver will
be able to work on his own.
Needless to say, the higher the
quality of the training the more likely the new Delivery Driver will feel
confident in his job performance, improve his own productivity in a short
time, and be less likely to seek employment elsewhere.
If you have position descriptions
for the Delivery Driver (and other positions) you should consult them to
ensure all the tasks identified within them are covered by the structured
on-the-job training program.
ANALYZE THE TASKS
After the tasks for the Delivery
Driver position have been identified you and your management team must
analyze their content, decide how best to provide on-the-job training to
the new employee, and who will do the training. For the sake of
demonstration we will briefly take a look at the aspects of hand-held
operations. The first question to ask is; Who is best qualified to teach
this task? Is it an existing Driver, the Route Supervisor or the Office
Manager? Make the decision and proceed with the next question. Where is
the hand-held training to take place? In the warehouse or out in the
market? Make the decision and proceed with the next question. Will the new
hire be required to perform all the hand-held operations immediately with
direction or will he be given demonstrations by the trainer? Make the
decision and proceed with the next question. Determine the point in the
training process where the employee will be required to operate the
hand-held for an entire day out in the market with minimal assistance from
the trainer.
Regardless of the tasks of the
position it is important they be broken down into individual points and
discussed to ensure the on-the-job training is the most appropriate for
the situation. Also remember; what is effective for one task will not
necessarily be the best for another.
DEVELOP TRAINING MODULES
OK. We now know who we are going
to train, when they are going to be trained, and the topics to be covered
in the training. The training modules are the heart of an effective
structured on-the-job training program. The training program for our
Delivery Driver will contain several modules. A training module for each
position task including package identification, morning check-out
procedures, lifting, 2-wheel operations, customer service, rotation,
merchandising, hand-held operations, and check-in procedures will need to
be assembled.
Each module will contain all the
steps, points and procedures that must be learned if the new employee is
to be able to perform the job by himself. Using the hand-held operations
as an example the training module would include at least the following:
The training module does not have
to contain every small action; however it should contain a list of the
major actions and/or steps of each task. The module may be used as a
checklist by the trainer to ensure all steps have been covered. It can
also be used by a supervisor to review with the new employee all the
aspects of the module. Most training modules can be reduced down to one or
two printed pages that list all the steps of each task. Getting more
detailed than this changes the training from on-the-job to a passive
reading of procedures. Keep the modules short and in list form; allow the
trainer to use his knowledge and skill to train the new employee in a
flexible and interactive manner.
After you have completed all the
training modules for the Delivery Driver position give them to those
individuals that have a good knowledge of what is expected of a Delivery
Driver. Solicit feedback on the modules, make improvements, and then test
them using a new employee in a real-life training situation. Again solicit
feedback from both the employee and the trainer; make improvements if
necessary to refine the modules. Once you and your staff are satisfied
with the Delivery Drivers training modules select the next position and
begin the process again.
On-the-job training with quality
trainers is probably the most cost effective means you have available to
improve the productivity of your distributorship. Although the assembly of
training modules may seem like a lot of work their usefulness in the field
is invaluable. They help keep both the trainer and new employee focused
upon the task at hand.
SELECT THE TRAINERS
Having prepared training modules
reduces greatly the need for a formal "train-the-trainer"
program. The entire concept of on-the-job training is to convey the job
knowledge of the trainer to the new employee in a real-life setting. For
the on-the-job trainers it is more important for them to have good work
practices and a strong desire to be a trainer than to have formal
training.
In an ideal setting all
experienced workers should be qualified as on-the-job trainers. You may
want to consider including the role of trainer as part of the Delivery
Driver position description and performance evaluation.
The attributes that an on-the-job
trainer must have to be effective include:
Interestingly, these attributes
are no different than those desired by every beer distributor for all
their drivers.
PREPARE THE TRAINEE
The next stage of the structured
on-the-job training program is to prepare the new employee for the
training. This can be accomplished during the employees' first day on the
job. Typically the first day is set aside for the completion of employment
paperwork, introduction to other employees, orientation to the company and
its policies and procedures. Completing a review of the structured
on-the-job training program should also be included. The training will be
more effective from the start if the new employee knows exactly what is
going to be happening to him in the next few days and weeks. Nothing
creates more unnecessary turnover with new employees than keeping them
uninformed about what is happening with them in their new place of
employment.
Structured on-the-job training,
by its very nature, does not allow the new employee to become a "lazy
learner". If the new employee truly wants to ensure his success he
must become proactive in the development of his skills and knowledge.
DELIVER THE TRAINING
We're ready to go. We have a new
employee that we are going to train to be a Delivery Driver. You now need
to decide which of the trainers will deliver the various modules. With
some distributors it works best if the new employee is assigned to one
trainer that covers all the modules. With other distributors a team of
trainers are used to deliver the modules.
In the multiple trainer situation
the trainer who is best at instructing in the operation of the hand-held
is assigned to work with the new employee on this module. Another driver
(trainer) is assigned to train the new employee in the art of display
building. Depending on the training topic of the module the new employee
will spend one or two days, a week or more learning the tasks outlined in
the module. The new employee will not progress to the next module until
the trainer is satisfied he is able to complete all of the tasks of the
module correctly without assistance.
REMEDIAL TRAINING
Structured on-the-job training
does not need to be limited to just new employees. Within many
distributorships there are individuals not performing all the tasks of
their position. Having a structured on-the-job training program is a great
tool to use with experienced employees that are having difficulty with
certain aspects of their position. You do not need to use all the modules;
retrain the existing employee(s) only in the tasks (modules) they are
having difficulty performing.
CROSS TRAINING
Cross training, the training of
employees to perform each others duties, and structured on-the-job
training; what a great combination! Effective cross training of your
employees will always put you ahead of your competition when it comes to
market execution and customer service. A properly designed, supported, and
implemented structured on-the-job/cross training program is not only cost
effective; it will give you an excellent return on your training
investment.
PROVIDE FEEDBACK
When assistance is needed it
should be given in a constructive and positive manner. When a new employee
"just doesn't get it" the trainer and the supervisor need to
discuss the situation and determine if more time is needed, a different
trainer is required, or the employee should be terminated. There is no
benefit to your organization to have half trained or incompetent
employees. Not all turnover is bad.
EVALUATE THE RESULTS
Significant results from
structured on-the-job training will not be evident within a month, a
quarter, and perhaps not even in the first year. At the beginning of the
program you established objectives for the program. Do not lose sight of
them just because the results will take a while to appear. This is a
long-term effort to improve your rotation, vehicle operating costs,
overtime, damaged product, reduced turnover, etc. Like all long-term
efforts results will only be forthcoming when the program is followed,
feedback is given, and adjustments are made; success can only be achieved
by staying the course.
PROGRAM BENEFITS
Reducing turnover, improving
rotation, controlling overtime, and having less damaged product are all
obvious benefits to your beer distributorship. There are however other
benefits that will be coming your way with the implementation of a
structured on-the-job training program. You will have fewer retailer
complaints, improved teamwork, and better market execution.
Your distributorship is not the
only beneficiary of a structured on-the-job training program.
Professionally trained employees will function better, feel better about
their employer, be part of an effective team, grow their income, and
obtain promotions. These benefits, although not always measurable, may be
the greatest benefit to your bottom line.