MANAGING THE IMPLEMENTATION OF CHANGE
By
Sam Boyer
Change within the beer distribution industry is
coming at a faster rate than ever before. Between new product
introductions and the rapid advancement of technology just keeping up is
becoming a monumental task. All of us make minor changes daily to
operations; it's part of our routine. But it's the major changes such as
consolidation of operations, a new building, route realignment, or a new
computer system that can make or break your organization.
Managing the implementation of these major changes is a
must if you are to survive in today's highly competitive environment.
Attempting to implement major changes without a well thought out plan will
result in wasted efforts, lost time, missed sales, and lower profits.
Major changes within organizations are required for long term survival.
Getting these changes implemented as smoothly as possible with a minimum
of disruption is a difficult, but manageable task. A well thought out plan
for managing the implementation of changes includes:
ANALYZE YOUR SITUATION
Before you can even begin to think about implementing a
major change you must know exactly where you are in all the critical areas
of your organization. If you don't know exactly where you are, it will be
impossible to decide where you want to go. Additionally, you won't know
which changes to implement in order to get there.
Knowing the impact of the changes prior to their
implementation is a must. Converting to pre-sell without knowing its
impact on administrative operations is a set-up for failure. Prior to the
implementation of any major change you must analyze its impact on the
sales and delivery routes, compensation, training, warehouse, inventory
control, administrative operations, and policies and procedures. All of
these areas will be affected by a new computer system, route realignment
or new building.
DEVELOP A VISION
Changes made without an established vision are doomed
to failure. Changes are made to organizations in order to achieve a
vision. Yourselves and your employees must know exactly where the
organization is going. Your vision becomes the point upon which all of you
can focus as you go through the difficult tasks of change.
You must emphatically support the vision. Just stating
the vision will not do. You must support all aspects of the vision. You
can do this by personally putting a significant amount of time and energy
into achieving it. Anything less will send a signal to the employees that
the vision does not have your uncompromising support. Without support the
changes will fail and your vision will not be achieved.
SELL THE CONCEPT
After you have analyzed your distributorship, know its
status, and have developed a vision of where you want it to be you have to
sell the concept of change. For some this will be an easy task, for others
very difficult. Those having an effective management style and the respect
of their employees will be able to present and sell the concept of a
changing organization. It will be easy because your employees trust your
judgment and are willing to follow your lead.
Those who do not have an effective management style
will have a more difficult time. You will have to walk each member of your
management team through the logic of the vision. After they are
comfortable with the vision you will need to sell each of them on the
concept of change. This will be the most difficult part; individuals
generally do not like change. However, if you are to achieve the vision
you have for your organization you must sell the concept of the needed
changes.
After the management team is on board with the vision
and the concept of changes, use them to sell the employees. Work with each
manager to sell his or her direct subordinates. A unified management team
will be able to sell the vision and concept of the needed changes.
IDENTIFY THE CHANGES
OK, you have analyzed your situation, developed a
vision for your organization, and you have successfully sold the concept
of changes to your management team and employees. What is next? Identify
what needs to be changed in order to achieve your vision.
What needs to be changed will vary widely depending
upon the vision you have for your organization. Each function of the
organization must be reviewed under the guise of "in order to achieve
the vision will this function need changing?"
Will the achievement of the vision require changes in
the sales and delivery routes, compensation system, product line,
training, warehouse operations, organization structure, inventory control,
job descriptions, office operations, policies, and/or procedures? They all
must be examined to ensure they support the vision.
COMMUNICATIONS ARE ESSENTIAL
Excellent communications are critical if you are to
manage the needed changes and not be managed by them. As soon as the
needed changes have been identified communicate them to the employees.
This will stop the rumor mill.
Rank the changes according to the relative importance
to achieving the vision. Focus in on the key areas and begin working on
them first. Success in key areas will not only give you an excellent start
towards achieving your vision but it is also the best means of
communication. Success breeds success. Success in a key area communicates
to the employees the changes are necessary.
Your employees will be fearful of the changes. You must
use communications to fight this fear. Listening to and responding
positively to their fears will put most resistance to rest. You and the
management team must have a positive attitude about the changes. Not
having a positive attitude is easily detected by (and communicated to) the
employees. When employees lose faith in the leadership the changes will
not be effective. You must achieve success in a key area early and
maintain a positive attitude throughout. This is the best form of
communication.
DEVELOP STRONG SYSTEMS
Many of the changes implemented within beer
distributorships are enhancements to management systems. Developing strong
new systems will have a much better chance of success than weak systems.
If you are going to go through all the work of making changes to your
management systems make them worthwhile.
How can you do this? First, do not accept that there is
only one way changes can be made. Demand from your managers different
alternatives along with the good and bad points for each.
Second, do not implement immediately. Allow a few days
or weeks to go by prior to implementation. This will give everyone
involved time to consider the new management system and come up with
adjustments to it.
Third, after the system is implemented stick with it.
Do not allow it to "fall out." If it does all future change
implementations will be in jeopardy of failure. You may have to make minor
adjustments to the system, but do not depart from your initial commitment
to it. If you did the "up front" work of analyzing, designing
and reviewing of alternatives your new system will work.
PROMOTE EMPLOYEE PARTICIPATION
You cannot implement changes in a vacuum. The
involvement of your managers and employees is required. If you are
changing your routes who better to provide input into their structure than
the salespersons and drivers who are involved with them every day. This is
not to say that they should have the ultimate say in the route structure,
but they must have the opportunity to provide significant input.
Without participation employees will not "buy
in" to the changes you need to make. Employees that do not have the
chance to "buy in" to the changes will have a stronger tendency
to resist them. Given enough resistance, the changes you implement will
fail.
One method of gaining employee support is to promote
the idea that the changes will not only create opportunities for the
organization but also for those employees who excel after the changes.
EXPECT RESISTANCE
No matter how much analyzing, planning, and employee
participation you do, some of your employees will resist the changes. The
majority of human beings naturally resist change. Change takes employees
(and some Presidents) out of their comfort zone and places them in an
unknown situation. This results in resistance to the needed changes.
Resistance comes in two forms: overt and passive. Overt
resistance is the easiest to overcome. It comes from the employees who
openly oppose the changes. Allow these employees to speak their mind and
then work with them to overcome their concerns.
Passive resistance is much tougher to overcome. If you
don't know it exists you cannot overcome it. The most passive resistance
comes from employees who have no opinion when asked about the proposed
changes. Everyone has an opinion, be very careful and watchful of those
who do not express it when asked. After passive resistance is detected
take immediate action to eliminate it.
DEAL WITH THE STRESS
Changes not only create resistance but also stress.
After the changes are in place for a period the stress will subside by
itself. Initially, however, you must work to reduce it. If you don't a
high stress level could cause the changes to "fall out." The
best means of reducing the stress brought on by change is to make sure all
communications possible is taking place.
Without communications the stress will build to
dangerous levels. You and the management team must be asking questions of
the employees at all possible times. After a route realignment be present
in the building when drivers and salespersons return to ask them how their
day went, what problems they encountered, and the success they had.
Giving them this opportunity to vent their feelings
will go a long way towards stress reduction. If you don't take this step
your employees will internalize their stress and cause you future problems
and more resistance. Just listening to the employees most affected by the
changes will reduce their stress and maybe even yours.
DEMAND FEEDBACK
If your changes are going to truly help achieve the
vision you have for your organization feedback is essential. You cannot
drop your guard once the changes are working. Now is the time to evaluate
the changes and expected results.
There is no better time to fine-tune the changes than
shortly after the implementation. Communications with the management team
and employees is essential. Each member of the management team should be
required to prepare an evaluation of the new systems, routes, etc. and
what effect the changes have had on their responsibilities. They should
also be asked if additional fine-tuning is needed to achieve an even
better result.
Thirty days after the implementation performance
evaluations on all managers and employees may be appropriate. This will
give your employees the feedback necessary to improve their performance
within the new systems, routes, etc.
Without feedback employee performance will not be where
it could be, the changes implemented will not be as effective as they
should be, and the vision you have for your organization will not be
realized.
CONCLUSION
Managing the implementation of changes is not easy or
simple. It is time consuming and stressful. However, by following the
steps outlined above it is manageable.
Change within the beer distribution industry is
constant. Make the changes within your organization in a timely and
orderly manner before the market, competition or suppliers force you to
make them. To achieve the vision you have for your organization make the
needed changes now. You will be more successful.